Jamie Carragher thinks key Tottenham man is ‘done’ after recent results

Tottenham Hotspur’s 4-3 loss to Chelsea on Sunday added another bitter chapter to their frustrating 2024/25 campaign. Ange Postecoglou’s side started strong, surging to a 2-0 lead within 11 minutes, only to collapse and allow their London rivals to overturn the deficit.

For Spurs fans, the defeat was a bitter pill to swallow, especially given the high expectations at the start of the season. This latest setback leaves Tottenham in 11th place in the Premier League, with only six wins from their opening 15 games and just one victory in their last seven matches. The pressure is mounting on Postecoglou as questions swirl about his ability to lead the team back to its former glory.

However, the scrutiny is not solely focused on the manager. Daniel Levy, the club’s long-serving chairman, also finds himself under increasing criticism. Sky Sports pundit Jamie Carragher weighed in after the match, suggesting that it might be time for Levy to step aside.

According to Carragher, while Levy has made significant strides in developing the club’s infrastructure, including the state-of-the-art Tottenham Hotspur Stadium and upgraded training facilities, his tenure has failed to deliver success on the pitch.

Carragher argued that the lack of trophies during Levy’s reign indicates that a change in leadership might be necessary to take the club to the next level.

Carragher’s comments reflect a growing sentiment among Tottenham supporters who have grown impatient with the club’s inability to win silverware. Despite significant investments in the squad, including the record-breaking £65 million signing of Dominic Solanke this summer, Spurs have not won a trophy since their League Cup triumph in 2008.

The lack of tangible success has overshadowed the impressive off-pitch developments under Levy’s leadership. Fans, who invest significant time and money in supporting the team, are understandably frustrated by the disconnect between the club’s ambition and its achievements.

Tottenham’s struggles in recent years have also seen the departure of key players like Harry Kane and Gareth Bale, who sought greater success at bigger European clubs.

These high-profile exits underscore the challenges the club faces in retaining top talent when it fails to consistently compete for major honors. While Levy’s tenure has undoubtedly elevated Tottenham’s stature in many respects, Carragher’s argument that the club needs a new direction to achieve sustained success on the pitch holds weight.

The pressure on Postecoglou further complicates matters. Tasked with restoring the team’s fortunes, the Australian manager has faced a difficult start to his tenure. The team’s inability to capitalize on strong positions in games, as seen in the Chelsea match, highlights ongoing issues with consistency and resilience.

Injuries, tactical missteps, and a lack of squad depth have all played a role in Tottenham’s underwhelming performances this season. While Postecoglou has shown glimpses of promise, the growing demands for immediate results make his position increasingly precarious.

The January transfer window could offer an opportunity for Tottenham to address some of their shortcomings. Reinforcements, particularly in defense and midfield, could provide the depth and quality needed to stabilize the team and improve results.

However, with mounting pressure on both Postecoglou and Levy, the decisions made during this period will carry significant weight. The club’s ability to navigate this critical juncture will likely determine the trajectory of their season and shape their long-term prospects.

The debate over Levy’s future as chairman encapsulates the broader challenges facing Tottenham. On the one hand, his contributions to the club’s growth and modernization are undeniable.

The Tottenham Hotspur Stadium is widely regarded as one of the best football venues in the world, and the club’s training facilities rank among the finest in Europe. On the other hand, football is ultimately judged by success on the pitch, and in this area, Tottenham has consistently fallen short. The lack of trophies under Levy’s leadership has become a glaring omission, fueling calls for a change in direction.

For Tottenham, the road ahead is fraught with uncertainty. The team must find a way to halt its downward spiral and rediscover the winning mentality that has eluded them in recent years.

Whether this involves a change in leadership at the executive level, a shift in managerial approach, or a combination of both, it is clear that the status quo is no longer sufficient. The club’s passionate fanbase deserves a team that can compete at the highest level and deliver the success they have long yearned for.

As Tottenham navigates this critical period, the stakes could not be higher. The decisions made in the coming weeks and months will shape the club’s future and determine whether they can finally fulfill their potential.

For Postecoglou, Levy, and the players, the challenge is to rise above the adversity and prove that Tottenham Hotspur can be a force to be reckoned with once again. Only time will tell if they can meet this challenge and bring the success their supporters crave.