Tottenham Hotspur may already have their new Harry Kane, and he could be the perfect replacement for Randal Kolo Muani. For years, Spurs fans have heard the same story Tottenham need a striker.
The departure of Harry Kane left a void so immense that any player stepping into his shoes would inevitably be under enormous pressure. Kane’s legacy as Tottenham’s all-time leading scorer and England’s record marksman makes him irreplaceable in many ways.
Yet football never stops, and every end brings a new beginning. Now, as Spurs deal with injuries up front, a young star might be ready to step forward and carry the torch.
Replacing Harry Kane was never going to be easy. The England captain scored 280 goals in 435 appearances for Spurs, setting a record that may stand for decades.
His consistency, intelligence, and ruthless finishing made him not just a goalscorer but the heartbeat of Tottenham’s attack. Below is a look at the club’s all-time top scorers, a list that defines the greatness Kane achieved.
| Tottenham’s All-Time Record Scorers | Apps | Goals |
|---|---|---|
| Harry Kane | 435 | 280 |
| Jimmy Greaves | 376 | 266 |
| Bobby Smith | 316 | 211 |
| Heung-min Son | 454 | 173 |
| Martin Chivers | 350 | 167 |
| Data via Transfermarkt |
After Kane’s exit to Bayern Munich in 2023, Tottenham turned to Dominic Solanke as their long-term solution. Signed for £55 million, the former Bournemouth striker was seen as a player who could grow into the role.
However, injuries have plagued his progress, and he is now ruled out until at least December under Thomas Frank’s management. This left Spurs relying on loanee Randal Kolo Muani, who was brought in from Paris Saint-Germain last August for the 2025/26 campaign.
Kolo Muani arrived with high expectations. The French forward had impressed during a loan spell with Juventus, scoring 12 goals and earning praise for his dynamic, modern style of play. Tottenham believed they had secured a smart addition fast, technically gifted, and capable of leading the line.
But his start in North London has been hampered by injuries. After missing the early part of the season, Kolo Muani returned to start three of Tottenham’s last four league games but failed to record a goal or an assist. Then came another setback.
During the match against Manchester United, the 26-year-old was withdrawn at half-time. Medical assessments later revealed a fractured jaw, ruling him out for up to eight weeks.
This fresh injury blow leaves Tottenham short once again, with Solanke and Kolo Muani both sidelined. However, in the midst of this crisis, a golden opportunity has emerged for one of the club’s brightest young talents Dane Scarlett.
Scarlett, only 21 years old, has been quietly developing his game after a series of loan spells. A graduate of Tottenham’s academy, he made his first-team debut under Jose Mourinho in 2021. Mourinho famously described him as a “diamond” of a player raw, talented, and destined for great things.
Fast forward to today, and Scarlett is once again knocking on the door of the first team. He was part of the squad that faced Copenhagen in the Champions League last week, coming off the bench and showing glimpses of his potential.
The young striker shares many traits with Harry Kane. He’s quick, intelligent with his movement, and composed in front of goal. Thomas Frank has praised Scarlett’s finishing ability, calling him a “fantastic finisher” and someone who understands space and timing.
Those are the very qualities that made Kane a generational talent. While it would be unfair to burden Scarlett with immediate comparisons, he now has a rare chance to stake his claim in the absence of both senior strikers.
Scarlett’s rise could not come at a better time. Tottenham’s start to the season has been inconsistent, with flashes of promise overshadowed by missed opportunities in attack.
The team has often struggled to convert dominance into goals, a problem that has become more visible with key forwards out injured. A young and hungry striker like Scarlett could inject much-needed energy and unpredictability into the attack.
It’s worth remembering that Harry Kane’s own journey began under similar circumstances. He was not an overnight success; he earned his place through patience, hard work, and seizing opportunities when they came.
Scarlett has already scored his first senior goal for Tottenham under Ange Postecoglou in the Europa League last season, and with the current shortage up front, he could now become a vital figure in Frank’s system.
Tottenham fans have been waiting for someone to step up and lead the line with authority. Scarlett’s blend of pace, sharpness, and composure in front of goal gives him the tools to do just that. His development has been carefully managed, and now, with both Solanke and Kolo Muani unavailable, the stage is set for him to shine.
This could be the moment Tottenham’s academy once again delivers a homegrown hero. Just as Kane once rose from within to become a club legend, Scarlett has the chance to follow a similar path. He may not yet have the experience or the numbers, but he possesses something equally valuable a fearless desire to prove himself.
Tottenham’s hunt for their next great striker might not require another big-money signing after all. The answer could already be wearing their shirt. In Dane Scarlett, Spurs might have found not just a replacement for Kolo Muani, but the beginning of a new era one that could see the legacy of Harry Kane continue through the next generation.
